Proving Trig Identities
An identity, is an equation that is true for all "X" values. Calculators can help us prove when an equation IS NOT an identity. However calculators cannot prove if an equation IS an identity. This is because a graphing calculator cannot display all values of "X" at one time. The display window in restricted to a finite number of values. This is problematic because if there is even one point where the two lines aren't the same outside the view able window, it wouldn't be an identity. To prove my above-stated point, I will prove that a trig equation isn't an identity, and show that a trig identity can't be proven with a calculator, but algebraically.In sum:
a. Find an equation that is not an identity. Use your calculator to demonstrate that it's not an identity. Be creative. Take screen shots, pictures, images, etc.b. Find an identity. Use your calculator to show what an identity looks like on the screen. Be creative. Take screen shots, pictures, images,etc.c. Why can you not prove an identity using the graphing or tables tools? Explain.
A. I think we can all agree that tanx/secx=csx/tanx isn't true. It would be an identity if all values of x were the same for both graphs were the same(the lines would be the same).
Obviously this isn't an identity and this can be proved by the calculator.
B. Let's take the equation (cot^2x)7 = (1 + cosx^2)7
so while this looks like an identity, we cannot prove it with just this image. What if there where an inconsistency outside of the view-able frame? Then it wouldn't be an identity. So, we have to prove it algebraically. This is done as such: